The young man was killed during the clashes the city had seen before she left with the family in late 2017, and was hurriedly buried while the Global Coalition’s planes roamed the sky and gunfire from all sides filled the air.

In her daily search for the apple of her eyes, Mrs. Nawfa has repeatedly visited organizations concerned with missing persons, affiliated with the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria which controls the city, as well as the concerned individuals in the Raqqa’s Civil Council’s first Responders Team, but always came back empty-handed.

On a ‘sad’ Raqqa night, as she described, and with the help of her neighbors, Nawfa buried her son with her own hands while tears ran down her face. She never imagined burying him at this place, next to Al Taj Wedding Hall, the place where she wished to have his wedding party, surrounded by family and relatives.

The hall is located in south Raqqa, next to the old bridge. Before the war, it was a place to spread joy, a destination for the neighborhood and surrounding neighborhoods to have wedding parties, but it soon became a gloomy place shrouded in darkness, remembered sadly and sorrowfully by Raqqa’s people and all Syrians, because they buried their children and loved ones in a mass grave next to the hall and named after it, “Al Taj Mass Grave.”

Al Taj grave, or “the grave between bridges” as the residents call it because it’s located between the old and the new Raqqa bridges, was founded hurriedly by the residents at an open piece of land with red soil over an area of 4 dunams (around 4000 m2) at a crossroads next to a bypass road, in order to cover dead bodies during the fierce battles between ISIS and the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), which took control over the city on 17 October 2017, backed by the US-led global coalition.

“After the burial, I left the city as the battles got fiercer at the last days of defeating ISIS. After a few months, I was able to go back to the war-wrecked city, full of hope of visiting the grave that entombed his body so I could bury it at a proper place and be able to visit him, like others who lost their loved ones,” said Nawfa.

But Mrs. Nawfa did not foresee what actually happened. When she visited Al Taj mass grave, she did not find her son’s grave, as the place had transformed after moving the graves to another place. The once-famous hall was also completely removed by the end of 2017.

“The bodies were hurriedly exhumed from Al Taj grave, as I was told by a volunteer in the team working on exhuming the bodies, and the bodies were then moved to Tal Al-Bay’a Cemetery (east Raqqa) and were buried there. And when I asked him about my son’s body, he said we don’t know.. it might have been buried with the piles of bodies,” Nawfa added.

Like Mrs. Nawfa’s son, two successive global coalition airstrikes on Raqqa in the early hours of 12 October 2017 ended the lives of the 80-something Mohammad Fayyad Abu Seif and 16 other family members (Mohammad al-Fayyad and his three daughters, Ammar al-Fares, Yusri Abdul Aziz, Rezqeya (child), and Salem Hamad) and their neighbors, after the air raids destroyed his house and his brother-in-law’s (Hussein Hamad al-Fares) house in a narrow street at the middle of Raqqa, according to a detailed survey by Amnesty International.

According to the testimony of a source close to the family and the testimony of the surviving neighbors, the man had lived in his house for 50 years and refused to leave his house when the military campaign on the city began, but the series of airstrikes led to his death and burial in a mass grave close to the ruins of his house. The remains were later moved to a cemetery outside the city without identifying bodies and recognizing victims.

The international law deals with mass graves as “crime scenes” and considers exhuming bodies from mass graves in primitive ways to be one of the reasons leading to concealing the traces of the crime or why and how the victims were killed. Bodies, where they are, and how they look are evidence that should not be tampered with before forensic and legal examination as a part of investigations, as explained by legal experts.

Which now makes finding and identifying the remains of a victim that was buried in a mass grave and moved somewhere else, like the remains of Nawfa’s son, nearly impossible.

Dr. Mahmoud Kahil, forensic expert, argues that “the main problem with the process of moving mass graves is that it will cause the identities of the dead people to be lost and take away their families’ right to identify them.”

“In mass graves, there are no identification documents with the remains, not one piece of evidence, thus, the identified bodies are only the bodies that were buried in homes or were under fallen ceilings. The rest of the bodies have no papers.”

– Yasser al-Khamis, head of the Syrian Missing Persons and Forensic Team in Raqqa Civil Council (First Responders Team)

In the year when al-Fayyad’s family and Mrs. Nawfa’s son were killed, another 1600 civilians were killed in air and artillery bombardment by the coalition according to documentations by Amnesty International and Airwars, after an analysis of 200 airstrike sites, while others were killed as a result of battles, bombardment, and blockade targeting the city.

Moving the Remains Again!

In April 2013, ISIS announced its control over Raqqa, and in July 2014, a US-led coalition to defeat ISIS was formed.In 2016, US-backed “SDF” waged a campaign to take control over Raqqa, and was able to take control over it in October 2017.

As a result of these battles, Raqqa became the most destroyed city of the modern age, according to OCHAA, and around 80% of the city was left uninhabitable.

Amnesty International says that over 2500 bodies were exhumed from Raqqa, most of which are of civilians who had nothing to do with the conflict other than living on the battlefield. The organization believes that around 3 thousand bodies remain under the rubble or in mass graves, most of which are also civilians.

Its report, “Syria: War of Annihilation: Devastating Toll on Civilians, Raqqa ─ Syria” published in June 2018, describes the civilian’s situation as they are “killed by the coalition forces’ missiles, buried under the rubble, and killed by random artillery shells of the SDF, in addition to those killed by ISIS’ snipers and mines scattered on escape routes, in a strange joint mission to murder.”

A night before ISIS’ exit, besieged civilians had to bury their dead under fire, and since burial in public cemeteries became impossible, residents turned to burying their families and neighbors in public spaces, playgrounds, parks, and even inside and next to their homes or in random mass graves.After the SDF took control over Raqqa, the First Responders Team’s “body exhumation” department began examining mass graves and moving the remains outside the city to cemeteries that were especially made to entomb the remains of those who were in mass graves in Raqqa.

Al Taj mass grave, south of Al Taj hall, from which the process of moving the remains took over a month, from 6 June to 26 July, was only one of 28 graves from which the team has exhumed and moved bodies to other places.

The number of bodies exhumed by the team involving volunteers, diggers, and coroners, was over 6100 bodies, only 700 of which were identified and given to their families since the team started working on 9 January 2018. Thus, leaving the identities of 5400 bodies, among which the remains of Nawfa’s son, al-Fayyad’s family, and hundreds of others, unknown after the main mass graves were moved to bigger cemeteries outside the city (Al-Shohadaa, Tal Al-Bay’a, and Hittin) to be put in the ground there.

In a report obtained by the investigative team, ICMP states that exhuming bodies in primitive ways destroys important evidence and further complicates identifying bodies.

Yasser al-Khamis, who led the search and exhumation team, believes that the role of his team was relief in the first place, and that they worked without training, due to the dire need to move the bodies from the city upon the request and urge of the residents, who started returning after ISIS’ exit.“When we entered Raqqa, we saw bodies in the streets. The city was all piles of bodies, and people lived on top of them. The bodies were, for example, in the streets, between houses and buildings, in halls, on berms, in the Euphrates, and among farmlands. Can you imagine that I’ve found 60 bodies in a wedding hall.. and witnessed constructing a building on top of 10 bodies in Harat Al-Badw?”

Gravedigger

On 21 June 2018, the sun rose on the only sound heard in a number of Raqqa’s neighborhoods, the sound of hand shovels digging the ground, interspersed with the sound of wind passing between the branches of nearby pine trees.

Diggers were then wearing light medical masks, holding blue bags to put body parts and bones in them, and starting to exhume hundreds of bodies from Al Taj mass grave which started to smell like death.

A First Responders Team volunteer, who worked with the team as a digger in this grave at these moments on that day, describes it: “I, and the rest of diggers, were writing down in a chart basic details, like the type of the body, and then put the body in a blue bag and put it in a small van to move the body to rebury them a few kilometers away.

“At Al Taj mass grave, we handed over 31 bodies to their families, after identifying the bodies by personal belongings and documents, or clothes and distinguishing marks. ISIS’ members were also recognized by their clothes.. The rest of the bodies could not be identified, so we numbered each body bag and buried them in Tal Al-Bay’a cemetery.

The digger did not know whether al-Fayyad and his family were among the bodies which remains were moved, due to the difficulty of determining the identity and sex of the victims. What he did know, though, was that only 31 bodies were handed over to their relatives, while 371 bodies of people killed and hurriedly buried here were lost in suspicious circumstances.

The digger’s words intersects with a document obtained by the investigative team on Al Taj mass grave, referring to the exhumation of 402 bodies from the grave, among which 298 male, 36 female, 45 girls, and 17 people whose sex was not determined, according to the document. “We had a choice: either all the evidence (bodies) would be gone or we work on moving them while documenting the reason of death. After two months of work, we had a database, which now contains 6100 bodies. We recorded everything about the bodies, such as any distinguishing marks like a broken tooth or anything of this kind,” Yasser al-Khamis said.

Change of Rules of Engagement

Raqqa city was called the capital of ISIS. At the time, it was overcrowded with civilians, and before the last attack, it was bombarded by the global coalition aircraft as part of rules of engagement specifically targeting ISIS, and limiting civilian casualties.

However, those rules of engagement have changed when the city was subjected to land blockade, and ISIS fighters retreated inside the city, as the land and air forces loosened up some restrictions by US laws, which resulted in a catastrophic destruction of buildings and properties, and the death of civilians, according to rights reports.

The investigative team obtained a copy of the reports recorded by the first Responders Team after exhuming bodies, including details of number of bodies recovered, work days schedule, and the body’s sex, but lack any reference to any additional information or distinguishing marks or even photos of the clothes found next to the body.

This might be explained by the fact that his team has, since ISIS’ exit, started working on exhuming the remains from graves using simple and primitive ways, driven by the requests of the residents who began to gradually return to their neighborhoods, as they lacked experience in this field, and they were mostly regular workers, accompanied by a coroner, and did not use anything but traditional digging methods.

Al-Khamis admits that “there was a hurry to exhume bodies in a nonscientific way, but this was due to the continuous complaints by the residents and their requests to move the bodies in order for everything to be back to normal, so we had to move these bodies.”Um Faisal, a resident of Raqqa, lost her husband in 2012 after he was arrested by the Syrian regime’s intelligence services in Raqqa. Her eldest son, Faisal (18), was her only support, the man of the house despite his young age as she says, but she did not get the chance to rejoice in his youth, as she lost him during the battles Raqqa has witnessed, during the global coalition forces’ bombardment.

In her humble and semi-demolished house, comprising of two bedrooms and a small kitchen, surrounded by the ruins of a city which has not yet recovered from war, she says: “Don’t reopen my wounds again, I’m trying to heal.. Faisal was my home’s pillar after Abu Faisal was arrested, but I lost both the light and the pillar.. We were displaced to Kasrat in al-Birk and stayed there for five months. We crossed the Euphrates with my two young children, after the coalition targeted the bridges, and al-Birk was not safe as the air forces were also targeting boats, it killed many people.”

When the woman returned to the city and when the residents began to move the bodies from Al Taj grave, she went asking for help in moving her son’s body to Hittin cemetery. “I could not find my son’s grave, because the residents began moving their relatives’ bodies before the Responders Team intervened to take them out systematically… So, by the residents recovering their relatives’ bodies and digging the ground, the grave’s features changed and I didn’t know where exactly Faisal’s grave was anymore,” she says.

She adds, “When the First Responders Team started to relocate Al Taj grave, I did not find my son’s body among those they were moving or have allegedly documented. Thus, Faisal died twice, once due to the US-led Coalition aircraft, and the second time when I could not find his grave nor his body”.

Al-Khamis, who still leads the Syrian Missing Persons and Forensic Team, which consists of 43 people (including doctors, data entry clerks, jurists, officers, and engineers), says, “As a team, we did not blur evidence. On the contrary, we documented all undocumented bodies. Legal evidence might be lost, but the body eventually was buried in the cemetery after knowing the cause of death, bombing or execution, or of any other reason. We are proud of our work… our team did not sin but made a mistake… and making a mistake sampling and locating is better than making a mistake and losing the traces of the corpses completely”.

Bodies Hurriedly Buried

The Investigation Team obtained videos documenting the transfer of mass graves, and we also monitored the steps of the relocation, where bodies are placed in bags and then buried in cemeteries like Tal Al-Bay’a, located five kilometres east of Raqqa and considered a public cemetery.

The International Commission on Missing Persons, an international organization working to develop effective procedures for the protection of mass graves, confirmed that the exhumation according to the Commission’s documents requires the analysis of skeletal remains of mass graves and the collection of information on missing persons, the ability to conduct excavations, and the skills used to identify corpses and determine the cause of death.

Thirteen families from Raqqa, who we have contacted and are living in different geographical areas near the city, explained to us that the majority of corpses in mass graves belong to those who were killed by the bombing of the city and the battles the city has witnessed in the last weeks before being taken over and were buried in difficult conditions.“The families of the victims and those missing in mass graves deserve to know the fate of their children and to have access to justice. Preserving evidence from these mass graves is an essential part of this process”.

The Black Stadium

Ammar Gh. (43 years), from the city of Raqqa and works as a microbus driver to transport passengers on the Raqqa-Deir ez-Zor road, recalls how ISIS arrested his cousin in 2016 and put him in Al-Akirshi prison. They then transferred him to the Municipal Stadium in Raqqa (Black Stadium), which the organization used as a headquarter, only to be killed there by the Coalition bombing of the stadium in June 2017.

According to the information that reached the family, the young man was buried in Al-Fakhikha mass grave, south of the Euphrates river (Al-Kasrat area).

The family now thinks that the body of their son is located somewhere in Raqqa, after the transfer of corpses from Al-Fakhikha cemetery to Tal Al-Bay’a cemetery at the beginning of the year 2020. Ammar says, “The family has tried to find where the body of my cousin is through the Responders Team but there were no distinctive traces…In Tal Al-Bay’a cemetery (to where the bodies were transferred from the mass grave of Al-Fakhikha), many corpses were not recognized by the people… They are very large numbers .. thousands of bodies which were not identified because there is no DNA testing device”, as he said.

The young man holds the international community and international organizations accountable for that, as they did not probably and quickly help to identify the dead and the fate of the bodies, as the capabilities of the forensic doctors are limited, the Responders Team work is slow, and there are no DNA testing devices.

“People are waiting impatiently”, he says. He pointed out that getting DNA test devices and identifying the bodies is the only way to determine the identity of more than 5 thousand unidentified bodies.

The Forensic and Missing Persons team has always complained about the lack of support and experts in archaeology and anthropology. Yasser Al-Khamis, who leads the team, agrees with what Ammar and the rest are saying and calls for the need to provide such devices that make the work of the Forensic team much easier. He says, “We need DNA test devices, as well as intensive training courses to deal with the situation”.

For his part, Fadel Abdul Ghany, Head of the Syrian Network for Human Rights, calls the Central Tracing Agency, run by the International Committee of the Red Cross, to start aiding in the search for thousands of missing persons in Syria, and trying to reveal their fate, which is a way to help determine the fate of the bodies and the missing, according to him.

Where is My Brother’s Body?

Fayez (41 years), from Raqqa – Ben Al-Jisreen, has lost his brother Salah (43 years) during the battles and fighting between SDF and ISIS near Al-Karajat area, at the end of 2017.

We got a number to contact him via WhatsApp to find out the fate of his brother’s body, and we found out that he is currently out of Raqqa and living in Turkey as a refugee. He agreed to speak on the condition that his full name not be disclosed because his family is still in Raqqa.

Fayez narrates the details of the story, recalling when his brother Salah left home one afternoon “to search for a place from which he could secure bread or anything to eat from the shops near Al-Karaj {the garage}, but he was late until after the Maghrib call and did not come back, while we were home waiting for him to come back, not knowing it was the last time we would see Salah”.

The tall buildings in the area and near Salah’s home were stationed by ISIS snipers, and these buildings were largely targeted by the Coalition forces and the SDF. Used by the snipers, these building were thus destructed, while Ben Al-Jisreen area was targeted by SDF.

Every moving thing is a target, according to Fayez. He says, “Salah did not come back that day and there was no way to communicate with him. A resident of the neighborhood found his body with a sniper’s bullet in his chest, near Al-Karajat area, and was able to pull his body with some neighbors. They buried him in the nearby cemetery, where the people and ISIS buried the dead”.

While the former director of the forensic medicine authority in the Free Aleppo Governorate, Dr. Mohammad Kahil, considers that moving bodies from mass graves to other cemeteries without documentation is considered a crime on its own, in addition to the crime of murder.To this day, the family does not know who targeted Salah and put an end to his life, and Fayez does not know exactly what happened to his brother’s body after moving the graves outside the city after they left Raqqa and had the chance to go to Turkey through the city of A’zaz.

Praying on the Grave

In July of 2018, a Human Rights Watch report confirmed that, if workers continue to exhume the graves without appropriate technical training, equipment, and support, families may lose the chance to accurately identify the remains of their beloved ones.

According to the same report, “evidence related to the crimes in the area might be lost, including ISIS crimes and others”.

“We will not move any new bodies until we have received training, as well as devices to take samples from the bodies and reveal the reason of death”, Yasser Al- Khamis confirms the endeavour of his team in the coming days. Meanwhile, Um Faisal still hopes to find the grave of her son one day… Every day she goes to the place where he was first buried (Al Taj grave) and reads Al-Fatihah for his soul, then goes to where he was buried the second time (where his remains were transferred to the Hittin cemetery) and reads Al-Fatihah for his soul again, hoping her prayers will reach his soul and absent body.

As for Fayez, despite not knowing where his brother’s body is, who moved it, and how they did move it until now, he hopes to be able one day to stand at his brother’s grave, who left three kids behind, the oldest of whom is 8 years old and the youngest is 2 years old, to tell him what happened to their city, which was destroyed by the war.

*The investigation was done under the supervision of the Syrian Investigative Reporting for Accountability Journalism – SIRAJ, published on DARAJ.

The post Syrians Lose Their Relatives’ Remains After They Were Removed From Mass Graves appeared first on SIRAJ.

At Alderbasia city which affiliated to Al-Hasakah governorate, northern east of Syria, middle of November 2017 , the child Aven Sarokhan (12 years) was kidnapped in front of her school ,as her uncle Aram said  ,and he asserts that happened in conjunction with a campaign of kidnapping girls, whom they are same to her age, the fifth child in her arrangement between her sisters, who she was going to school for learning Kurdish language .

Her kidnappers denied “they are members of PKK (Kurdistan workers’ party)” that she was existed with them when her mother has gone to one of their headquarters in the city, “but due to existence of witnesses on the kidnapping accident in front of the school, they admitted in that and told her that she will follow a military course then we will returned her back “.

“They lost contact with her completely” as her uncle said, and her father later knew that she is existed on one of fronts in Dier Azzor, after publishing on one of the social media ” FaceBook ” affiliated to the units a photo for her between group of girls, and on the photo was written a comment saying ” your beauty & kindness… don’t hide the revolution which inside you”

“And even , If Aven was kidnapped and was recruited her by compulsory  ” as her uncle said. but story of the child Bashar Ahmad (14 years) has a different shape , being that he went by himself to  “swedkai ” encampment beside Almalkia at Al Hasaka countryside in November 2016 for training on carrying a weapon, and one of the encampment’s supervisor told his family when they came to visit their son that “you should forget your son ” he became son of the question , and he is not  your son after now” as a close source of the family said.

In this investigation  ,and during nine months , number of investigators has surveyed cases of recruitment children by through social media accounts (12 cases ) , and has observed of deaths announcements  , for 19 Childs under age of 18 , their ages average range between 12-17 years, when they has officially joined to the fighting , and they were held interviews with 7 child’s families ( 5 males – 2 females ) one of them killed on the fronts , and they were recruited in the ranks of ” People’s Protection Units YPG ” and in the factions which affiliated to it ,since of establishing the units in year 2012 until October 2018 .

The recruited children, some of them have dead at the fronts and the units has published his death , and others still fighting ,after their motives have  diversified for carrying weapon before reaching adulthood, and the investigation team has observed many methods for recruiting children and some it are innovative  ,and we are in the same time hide identities of some minors fighters , and the information resources , for their safety , because they still resident and working in areas of units’ control north of Syria & east  .

Recruitment the children in units’ control areas form a part from operations of recruitment children in Syria by the conflict’s parties , and in Arabian countries which have an armed conflicts ,”which multiplied through one year” , and In a report of united nations organization for childhood care “Unicef ” in September 2017 , that the number of recruited children in the middle east conflicts and north of Africa including Syria multiplied through one year , and that number of recruited children whom they have recruitment in the fight have raised from 576 of year 2014 to 1.168 cases of year 2015 “.

The painful side unfolds from size of the phenomenon through documented numbers by the Syrian organization “sound & picture”  during the last three years in areas of ” kassad’s” control, for the dead soldiers children , where killed 17 Childs under age of 18 years at least , by targeting locations affiliated to Kurdish Units or during the battles in Raqqa , Aleppo and Deir Azzor , “and these information were documented by one of children who recruited in 2016” as saying the organization director : Sarmad Aljailani .

Rates of the recruitment are rising to double

In a report issued in 3 august of 2018 , “Human Rights Watch” said that People’s Protection units  ,which are the largest member in the Syria’s Democratic Forces north eastern Syria and they are recruiting the children , between them girls , and they use some of them in the fighting works , in spite of their pledges to stop these thing .

Eight families in three camps for displaced people in north eastern Syria, the organization report said: that individuals from units of the people’s protection and “the Asayish” (police) at the camps have encouraged their children for joining. and these families said that six girls and two guys , their ages between 13 and 17 years were recruited , and most of the families couldn’t communicate with their children since recruitment of them , and they didn’t know , unless from the authorities, that the children were training.

One of the mothers  said that her son , who 16 years old when he recruited , and he had a fighting role then died during fighting of the group to recover Al Raqqa city .

Before that , in 16 May of 2018 , the annual report of the United Nations about  the children at the armed conflicts has mentioned that : /224/ recruitment cases for children by the People’s Protection Units and their female unit ,happened in year of 2017 ,in increase approximate about five double of the previous year 2016 , and it was 72 from the children , almost a third of the girls ,and in /3/ cases at least , the forces kidnapped the children to recruit them .

Jian A (alias name ) of Afrin population , she says at an interview with investigation team in middle of 2017 , which during it was recruited  her son Aldar compulsory at rows of the units of peoples’ protection last year :” my son was born in 2001 , was taken to the Refaat Martyr’s Center  (nearby Afrin ), after he signed a paper didn’t know its content , he don’t know reading or writing , and without his parents’ approval ,he went out of the home to fix his cell phone and returned back with military boots” in reference from  her for his readiness to join to forces rows .

The lady asserts that her son was recruited, in spite of his suffering from disease of Ischemia in the brain (it happens due to temporary interruption of blood supply to a part of the brain, and this disorders of blood supplies lead to lack of oxygen which reaches to the brain) and she was notified that son will return back as soon as finished off following the military course after he has got an alias name ” Avindar Afrin “.

The uncle’s wedding night

At 10:30 pm on 23 December 2017, a thirty years old youth holding Kalashnikov has stopped with 8 armed persons holding light individual weapons in front of wedding hall at Ain Arab– Kubani, the cold weather was harsh , and the most of whom were at the hall were starting to go out , during this night the youth Jwan Ahmad Muslem who is a leader of group in  Syria’s Democratic Forces has come , with his armed group and took out a child was attending his uncle’s wedding , and put him into a four-wheel car then they went to west of the city in 30 km to “Shuyukh Camp” .

At sunrise of the next day which didn’t adequate for making the parents of the child Kamiran Mustafa Allu (12 years) of” Yadi Qwi ” village south city of Ain Al Arab /Kubani /in  7 km to know , their child’s fate , who was arrested in his Uncle Ahmad’s wedding night . but later has shown by the investigation team that the child was kidnapped for compulsory recruitment purpose, that according to what mentioned from Shirazan Allu , the uncle’s son of the kidnapped child Kamiran , and he asserts that they enabled to  know that the child at the camp in Shuyukh’s Township at Jarablus countryside, ” and this camp is specialized in training of children ,and the camp have dozens of minors kidnapped children” according to Allu.

He is saying that “large number of the children have kidnapped in this camp, but families of those don’t have the courage to transfer their files to the media & the legal international organizations because the fear of the Repression”.

Using children in the aggressive works

And based to that recruitment of the children is against to the international conventions, where the optional protocol of the child rights which relates in  contribution of the children at armed conflicts ,is provides that : the armed groups which not affiliated to the state should not recruit the children under age of 18 years for any purpose . Thus the article 1 of the Child Rights’ Convention in the protocol determines that “the intended of child is every human his age under 18 years” according to the protocol.

And report of “recruitment children and using them in the aggressive works in the International Law of 2017″ which investigation team have obtained a copy of it , refers to continues of recruitment children at units’ areas after entering an amendment to a convention between them and International Organization , which was held to reduce this phenomenon, where ”the People’s Protection Units , Woman Protection’s Units and The Self Administration have signed on (the obligation deed ) by virtue of  Geneva Appeal .

that they will be forced a complete prohibition for using the children under age of 18 years at the aggressive works , but in contrary to the provisions of the optional protocol , the units entered a proviso ,which provides to allow for children of age /16/ years and above to become members at forces of People’s Protection Units by their own free will , and they will contribute in unmilitary activities , and they are not allowed to contribute directly or indirectly in aggressive works ” and  in June ” Geneva Appeal ” has announced that the group will amend the conduct rules’ blog , which they adopt it ,where is not allowed only who above 17 years or more for joining .

The writer Hoshank Awsi , living in Belgium and who is following-up the object of  recruitment of children ,is considers that the reason which makes the Democratic Union’s Party PYD and its military arm the People Protection’s Units YPG for recruiting children is its need to fighters , to fill of the fronts under the pretext of fighting” Isis” Organization and protects the Kurdish areas from the terrorist &  expiatory organizations , referring to that recruiting of the children is one of the supply resources of the fighters , and it is the wars’ fuels of the groups & and the armed parties.

he added that :” there is no another resource to supply the fronts by individuals unless two ways either by Persuasion and satisfaction or  the compulsory recruitment for minors & juveniles”.

Methods of the recruitment

the units attract the younger , according of children testimonies , their parents’ testimony , and legal  organizations , by establishing private grouping under name of “Kawminat ” one of it only to children.

the Kawmin is like a ” council of the neighborhood or the village “, and it is a name called  by the party to neighborhoods’ councils , and the first one of it was established at Afrin city in northern of Aleppo countryside in May of 2017 – before it controlled by armed forces of the Syrian opposition that supported by turkey in last March – in name of “Kawmin of the martyr Jilan Onkul for children “, and Jilan is Turkish girl of Kurdish origin , the supporters of  Kurdistan workers’ party is accuse the Turkish army in targeted her in Diar Baker’s State south of turkey in year of 2009 .

That The purpose of opening “Kuminat” of the children is “to organize, aware of them & developing of their cultural, artistic, educational talents &abilities.

The joint president of Afrin’s Kumin for children, Nawar Hasan, is saying in a press statement quoted by the Hawar agency, through events of opening the Kumin,” the children in this Kumin will learn a cultural, Intellectual, literary & educational lessons currently, and by passing of time will be there projects & another plans for developing of the children talents & their abilities ” and she called all the children’s parents to send their children to Kumin.

The attendance at the Kumin, and Learn about PYD Party principles and its thoughts considers a step in path of putting those children on the way of carrying the weapon, when they give them thoughts like “the revenge is the way of liberty” and ” we have been fighting the world for our leader “, as a legal activist of Arfin city are saying. He preferred not to mention his name for security reasons.

In a response published by ” Human Rights Watch” in 3 August of 2018 , which has reached  to it from the Self Administration authorities , after the organization’s inquiries of the recruitment children operation , and about putting the children in  Kuminat ,where the authorities have admitted in putting the children at private centers whom receiving inside it ” intellectual & occupational training “.

And the response, included reference for ” issuing of the General Command generalization for the people’s protection units & woman in not allow to contribute of whom less than 18 years at the aggressive works under penalty of the legal & moral responsibility, and in case it happened, it will be arrested the direct responsible, in addition to reduce the military rank and the penalty is will be tightened in case of repetition”.

The another way “the soft ” that attracts children by it, by entering of photos of the party & units’ fighters in the study curricula that has imposed by the party in its controlling areas   (the self administration areas), and by demonstrate of them as the typical human ethically, the national hero, and naming the streets & schools in names of the dead persons.

The writer Awsi is considers that ” recruitment the children ” is covered by national slogans that flirt the feeling & national emotions for Kurds , in consideration that this fighting is for the demands & legal rights  , but this conduct don’t not serves the national thoughts or the national project , and recruiting children according to the international law is a war crime and the war crimes are absolutely not serve the national & legal thoughts to any people “and he considered that ” recruitment of the children by the party, for fighting in another areas as Deir Azzor, Al Raqqa and Kubani (Ain Al Arab ) as a custom for it , and an old conduct “.

According to observers, the phenomenon of recruiting is a general status and not only restricted to the units but also it is sharing it with “Isis” organization and factions of The Armed Syrian Opposition.

And In terms of documentation the phenomenon internationally, Ani Massaghi director of the high commissioner’s office for human rights – the middle east  is saying to the investigation team that ” the office has documented number of recruitment children cases in Syria and notified about it , and as a part of working in this regard contributing the Monitoring and reporting mechanism which was assigned that by the security council regarding to the gross committed violations against the children in Syria “.

Online recruitment

At 4:00 pm, on the current 8 October, the girl Awish Bozan has gone from her home at Kharbisan village west of Ain Al Arab city – Kubani – and didn’t return yet.

After hours of her disappearances, the child’s family knew from command center of Democratic Union Party (PYD) that she was recruited at The Woman Protection’s Forces and it’s an armed military wing affiliated to the party , as her uncle Adnan Bozan is saying , in a private interview .

According to family’s card and page of the child Awish Bozan , has shown her date of birth on 1-1-2002 , so she didn’t exceed 17 years old , in spite of the family seeking to prove that to the concerned & officials persons on her recruitment but all their attempts did not success to recover  her , her uncle is saying ” we has presented the family card which regarding the child to democratic union’s party , and provided to them documents, but unfortunately without getting any benefit “.

Through following- up the child’s status by the family , as her uncle asserts to the investigation team , has  shown that Awish was convinced to join to the forces rows by social media, and according to her uncle that ” The Democratic  Union’s Party and the military wings which affiliated to it , uses methods for recruiting children by teams or private groups whom communicate with the children by social media or by the local people and they are lured , and at the neighborhoods there are individuals communicate with the children and spread ideas to facilitate attracting the children , like feeling in the freedom and independence and to be a lady of yourself and other of the ideas which the child is attracted behind it without conscious  “.

After the family knowing  in Awish’s fate, her uncle sent a humanitarian appeal to the local & international organization, asserting that “the operation of recruitment minors still continues at areas of The Democratic Party’s control “, and he added in publication across ” Facebook ” that the above mentioned ” recruits the children under the legal age at their camps and make them involved them in the armed conflicts in Syria, and that breaching to the laws & international humanitarian customs which related to  the children rights “.

A way to make money

Another factors make the children join to “fighter’s rows “, it is the family violence and pauperization, after the conflict caused all the last seventh years in rising up its rates to a standard levels.

A report was made by each of the committees of Economical & Social for western Asia , which affiliated to the United Nations (ESCWA) and Saint Androz British university, and it referred to ” that the numbers of Syrians whom living right now under the pauperization line are almost doubled three times and about 83.4 percent of the Syrians are living right now under the pauperization line in comparison with 28 percent of 2010″.

Hussein Alkhashman (14 years ) , of people of  “Sbaih ” village , which affiliated to Markada township in Al Hasaka countryside , we have met with one of his relatives at Al Shadadi , who refused to mention of  his name for security reasons , said that ” Hussein has joined in February 2017 to YPG due to the need of money without knowing his father , who lost the connection with him , and he has received an amount of /S.P 70.000/ monthly, ($ 145 U.S dollars ), and his armed work was at first only at  the work of guard and inspection patrols , then he forced to go in the last September with YPG armed fighters to Deir Azzor countryside for fighting Isis organization , then he has died over there in date of 24 in the same month ” and his death was announced by the official announcement of the People’s Protection Units .

The child ” Helal Jamil ” (alias name ) (17 years ) , one of Alshadadi city at southern of Al Hasaka countryside ,which controlled by PYD fighters ,  of a poor family , he explains that he felt jealous of his rich colleagues at schools , so one of his friends’ advice for him was to joint to ” Asayish” forces  (police forces ) which considered the security arm for the party in its control areas , against of S.P 54000 monthly ($ 110 U.S dollars ) .

Breyanka Motbarthi ,who are doing the works of emergency section’s director  in ” Human Rights Watch “said “if the children were run away of the family violence or poverty , the people ‘s protection units would not protect them through recruiting them in its forces . If they were serious in helping those children, they must fulfill their Commitments and provide the alternatives to guarantee that children will not lose their future or their live “.

Fighting roles & double crime

The investigation team communicated with Aldar Khalil , the political leader at Democratic Society’s  Movement , and with Moustafa Bali , the spokesman in name of Democratic Syria ‘s Forces , for giving them the opportunity of response and comment on the evidences which documented of the recruiting operations  and which proved its continuous in spite of promises to stop it , but no one of them respond until the moment of publishing the investigation .

But “Human Rights Watch “, in a letter for it on 29 June 0f 218 sent to Democratic Syria’s Forces and to the Executive Committee to “the Self Administration ” which affiliated to “Kurdistan Democratic Union Party ” requesting information of the procedures which were taken by the committee to prevent of recruiting & using them at the aggressive works , and they obtained a response was that ” will notifying the families when are recruiting the children , but the children can join by themselves also without approval of their parents”.

According to the legal organization, the letter admitted that the children whom ages ranged between 16 & 17 years old they can join, but they said that they will not do any fighting roles.

Another time, the investigation team went to confront Nouri Alkhalil , the official spokesman in name of People’s Protection Units,  about what was reached it, by the investigation team , and considered that the reports which were reported by the legal organizations about continuous of phenomenon of  recruiting children’s that it is ” old”, and he is ready to return the recruited children in his units’ rows whom we know them or we documented their joining to the units rows, to their family .

“The crime of recruiting children without approval of their parents is a double crime “as  was classified by writer & political analyzer Abdelbaset Seda, he considered that recruiting the people – even they were of adults – without of their approval and by the De facto authorities that don’t have any legitimacy, is a crime punished by the law , and that what have been doing by the PYD  units , which not provide itself originally as a Kurdish units “and ” in spite of the pressures on the party (PYD ), it will be continuous in the recruiting , and promises in the commitment, and they will be there pledges in stopping of recruiting children and commitment in the international laws which related  in wars & conflicts , and in his role the Syrian Kurdish writer, Hoshank Awsi saying , and he mentioned to that ” it will be thought about how to circumvent these promises, and the continuous of this conduct , because it is one of the sources of the supply of fighters”.

This investigative story was completed by Syrian Investigative Reporting for Accountability Journalism – (SIRAJ) In cooperation with NSO. Published on DARAJ.  

The post “Children of the issue” appeared first on SIRAJ.